How does one handle criticism? That is what we discussed this morning accompanied by our weekly indulgence in polycalorific, fat-enriched, omega-free doughnuts.
What type of criticism makes you snap back? In this post I want to make a few comments about responding to unjust and unfounded criticism.
Jesus suffered that kind of treatment, yet he did not retaliate. Instead, he “continued entrusting himself to him who judges justly” (1Pe 2:23b ESV). Jesus sets the example for those of us that follow in his way. Tempted as we may be to lash back at our critics, or to justify ourselves, we are called to suffer the injustice.
Doesn’t that seem like asking the impossible? I would say it is impossible if we are relying on our social graces to hold our response in check. I think we need to look deeper than “technique” to understand more fully how we might follow Jesus’ lead.
Foundational to Jesus’ response was his relationship with the Father. Vindication would come according to his Father’s timetable. Until then Jesus was secure in his relationship with the Father; he was loved by the Father and the Father was well pleased with him (see Mt 17:5). That committed and affirming relationship created an impermeable firewall against insults and criticism.
For many of us, our relationship with the Father in Heaven is not foundational to who we are as men. We have been beguiled by cultural sirens that bid us to build our identities on something other than on God. When that foundation is called into question, when people unjustly criticize what we do, or what we know or what we have, it is our identity that is being attacked. We can do nothing much other than to fight back.
In the context of Jesus not answering his critics, Peter reminds us:
For you were continually straying like sheep, but now you have returned to the Shepherd and Guardian of your souls. (1Pe 2:25 NASB)
I would suggest that we are not going to have much success in responding to unjust criticism until this truth becomes active in our lives. Our souls find their care, their keep and their security in God. The world may insult what I do, what I know, what I say, what I believe but it cannot call into question the merit and value of who I am, because my true identity has been committed to the care of the one who created me and called me into real relationship with him (see 1Pe 4:19). With that settled, I believe we like Jesus can leave our vindication up to God.